LOST Pre-Game: “What Kate Does”

The Desmond on Flight 815X, then, is probably a very different individual than the one we know. We don’t even know if Penny exists, but if she does, Desmond didn’t have to deal with her father pushing them apart. White Oracle didn’t talk him out of proposing. Heck, it’s possible that Desmond was never jailed as a deserter, since he left the army only when his 2004 consciousness inhabited his past body. Desmond is probably the person most changed in Timeline X. Unless he isn’t changed at all.