I may be crazy here, but this spring that they’re bring the wounded Sayid to? Do you think that’s where Richard brought Young Benry when he was shot? Lennon even echoes Richard’s statement from that episode “There are risks”. And then, they toss Sayid in the water and hold him under until he stops struggling. Then the Asian guy is surprised that he’s dead. Cause of death? Probably drowning. Jack tries to resuscitate him, while Kate protests. It’s almost an exact duplicate of the scene where Jack tried to save Charlie after Ethan left him hanging from a tree.
